Please note that we are using a new peer review form drawn from the scholarship evaluation criteria developed by Glassick et al. in Scholarship Assessed: Evaluation of the Professoriate.
Please complete the evaluation form below for each article emailed to you, knowing that each serves two purposes: to inform the editors about the publication-worthiness of the article and to give feedback to the author(s). For both reasons, please be generous in your notes about how the article may be improved, even those you recommend for publication.
The Michigan Journal uses a double blind review process. Identification of authors, institutional affiliations, etc. have been removed to minimize possible biases and assure the paper is rated on its own merits. Correspondingly, reviewers’ identities are withheld from author(s).
Reviews are due to the editor, Jeff Howard (email) no later than June 30th and preferably earlier. When you submit this form, you will recieve a copy via email for your records.